A good insurance broker matches you to the right cover, explains the fine print and stands in your corner at claim time. North Shore has brokers covering everything from home and contents to business, rural and life, so it helps to start with a shortlist of trusted names.
We have rounded up five of North Shore's most trusted insurance brokers, focused on the right cover, clear advice and real support when you need to claim. This is a general guide, not financial advice.
The top 5 insurance brokers in North Shore are 1. North Shore Insurance Brokers, 2. Penberthy Insurance, 3. Baileys Insurance, 4. Eclipse Insurance, 5. Donaldson Brown. Below we explain why each made the list, compare them at a glance, and share how to choose.
Showcase your business to customers exploring insurance brokers in North Shore.
Selected independently through our own research. How TopChoice works.
North Shore Insurance Brokers cover life, health, income protection, home and contents, business and mortgage protection.
Penberthy Insurance are an established insurance broker arranging business, home and contents and personal insurance.
A brokerage registered since 2014 covering business, house and contents, and boat insurance, with each arranged as its own policy rather than a bundle.
A Mount Roskill brokerage on the register since 2003, with business insurance as a dedicated service and mortgage advice alongside it.
An Auckland risk adviser registered since 2023, with a business insurance range set out product by product.
A quick comparison of our Top 5 picks. Select up to 3 businesses above to compare their strengths side by side.
| Insurance Broker | Best for |
|---|---|
| North Shore Insurance Brokers | Broad personal and business cover |
| Penberthy Insurance | Business and personal insurance |
| Baileys Insurance | Business, home and boat cover |
| Eclipse Insurance | Over twenty years broking |
| Donaldson Brown | Business cover, set out clearly |
Looking for insurance brokers in Takapuna or Devonport? Our recommended North Shore insurance brokers work right across the area, covering Takapuna, Devonport, Milford, Belmont, Birkenhead, Northcote, Glenfield, Castor Bay, Mairangi Bay, Browns Bay, Torbay, Albany and Beach Haven. Wherever you are, these are the insurance brokers North Shore locals rate.
Independent, editorial, and reviewed regularly.
TopChoice rankings are editorially curated by our New Zealand team and reviewed periodically. Our shortlists draw on public reputation signals from Google and other platforms, alongside our own research into each insurance broker. We weigh up a combination of:
We don't accept payment in exchange for a place in the Top 5. Rankings may change over time as businesses evolve. See how TopChoice works.
Decide what you need covered. Home and contents, vehicle, business and liability, rural, and life and health are different specialties, so look for a broker who regularly arranges your type of cover and works with a good range of insurers.
Check they are licensed and ask how they are paid. New Zealand insurance advisers operate under a licensed Financial Advice Provider and must disclose commissions or fees. A broker who compares several insurers can usually find better-value cover than going direct to one.
Claims support is where brokers earn their keep. Ask how they handle claims, whether they act for you when there is a dispute, and how easy they are to reach. Read the policy wording for excesses and exclusions before you commit.
A broker assesses your risks, compares policies from multiple insurers, arranges the right cover and helps you at claim time. They act as your adviser rather than for a single insurance company.
Not usually. Brokers are typically paid a commission by the insurer, and their buying power and access to multiple insurers can offset that. Any fees they charge must be disclosed to you up front.
Yes. Many North Shore brokers specialise in business cover, including public liability, professional indemnity, commercial property, vehicles and material damage. They can tailor a programme to your industry.
That is a key benefit. A good broker manages your claim, liaises with the insurer and advocates for you if there is a dispute over cover. Ask how hands-on they are before you sign up.
For simple cover, going direct can be fine. A broker adds the most value when you have multiple policies, business risks, higher-value assets or want someone to compare the market and handle claims for you.
You must answer questions honestly and disclose anything that could affect the risk, such as previous claims, alterations or how a property or vehicle is used. Your broker will guide you, and full disclosure protects your claim.
Our recommended North Shore insurance brokers cover Takapuna, Devonport, Milford, Belmont, Birkenhead, Northcote, Glenfield, Castor Bay, Mairangi Bay, Browns Bay, Torbay, Albany and Beach Haven, plus the wider North Shore area. Many also serve neighbouring suburbs, so it is always worth confirming your exact location when you enquire.
Editorial disclosure: TopChoice is an independent editorial platform. Some pages may include a clearly labelled TopChoice Spotlight placement for additional visibility, which never influences rankings within our Top 5 lists. See how TopChoice works.
Listed in the Top 5 insurance brokers in North Shore? Put the badge on your own site. It names your trade and your town, links back to this page, and there is nothing to edit. It is free, and taking it changes nothing about where you sit in our ranking.
Paste it into your footer or on your home page.
Showcase your services to customers exploring insurance brokers in North Shore. TopChoice Spotlight gives your business a prominent position on this page, supported by a dedicated profile and clear ways to contact you.
Explore Spotlight
